The Science of Carrier Oils: Comedogenic Ratings and Sebum Mimicry Explained
"Don't use oil on oily skin." "Oils will make you break out." Most of us have heard these warnings. Then some skincare blogs say jojoba is perfect for oily skin while coconut oil is not, which leaves many people unsure whether they should use oils at all.
The answer lies in oil chemistry. Every carrier oil is a mix of fatty acids, and that mix decides how it feels and whether it sits on your skin or sinks in. In this guide you will learn how to read the comedogenic rating of natural oils, what linoleic and oleic acids actually do, why jojoba is called a sebum mimic, and how to pick the right oil for your skin type.
Looking to buy? Explore our cold-pressed botanical oils, including jojoba, hemp seed and rosehip.
What Is a Carrier Oil?
A carrier oil is a plant oil pressed from the nuts, seeds or fruit of a plant. It can be used on the skin on its own or to dilute essential oils. Carrier oils nourish the skin by themselves, and you can read more in our guide to what a botanical oil is.
Not every oil behaves the same way. Some look thin in the bottle and vanish into the skin; others feel rich and stay on the surface. The main reason for this difference is each oil's fatty acid profile.
Oil Chemistry: Linoleic Acid vs Oleic Acid
Most plant oils are made of triglycerides: three fatty acid chains attached to a glycerol backbone. Which fatty acids an oil contains shapes how it feels and how it behaves on the skin.
Linoleic Acid (Omega-6): The Lightweight One
Linoleic acid is an omega-6 polyunsaturated fatty acid found in oils such as hemp seed, rosehip and sunflower. Oils rich in it feel thin and light, and they spread easily.
Linoleic acid is also a natural part of the skin's own barrier lipids. Studies on acne-prone skin have found that the sebum of people with acne tends to contain less linoleic acid. This is one reason linoleic-rich oils are often suggested for oily and breakout-prone skin.
Oleic Acid (Omega-9): The Rich One
Oleic acid is a monounsaturated fatty acid found in oils such as sweet almond, apricot kernel, moringa and avocado. These oils feel thicker and richer. With regular use they help soften dry patches and reduce water loss, which is why they are loved for dry, mature and weather-worn skin.
| Linoleic-rich oils | Oleic-rich oils | |
|---|---|---|
| Feel | Light, thin, dry-touch | Rich, slower to absorb |
| Absorption | Faster | A little slower |
| Best for | Oily, combination, breakout-prone skin | Dry, mature, dehydrated skin |
| Examples | Hemp seed, rosehip, sunflower | Avocado, sweet almond, apricot kernel, moringa |
| Shelf life | Shorter; oxidises faster | Longer; more stable |
What Is a Comedogenic Rating?
A comedogenic rating is a rough guide to how likely an ingredient is to clog pores and form comedones, better known as blackheads and whiteheads. It uses a scale from 0 to 5.
| Rating | Meaning |
|---|---|
| 0 | Unlikely to clog pores |
| 1 | Very low likelihood |
| 2 | Moderately low likelihood |
| 3 | Moderate likelihood |
| 4 | Fairly high likelihood |
| 5 | High likelihood |
Keep three things in mind:
- Processing changes things: a cold-pressed oil and a refined version of the same oil can behave differently.
- Concentration matters: an oil rated 3 may cause no trouble when it makes up only a small part of a blend.
- A rating is not an allergy test: a 0 rating does not mean an oil can never irritate your skin. Everyone's skin is different.
Comedogenic Rating of Natural Oils: The Chart
The ratings below are the ones most commonly cited. They vary between sources, so use them as a starting point, not a rule.
| Oil | Common rating | Main fatty acid | Feel and absorption | Best suited to |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hemp seed | 0 | Linoleic | Light, absorbs quickly | Oily, combination, acne-prone |
| Argan | 0 | Balanced oleic and linoleic | Light to medium | Normal, combination, mature |
| Sunflower | 0 to 2 | Linoleic | Light, dry-touch | Oily, combination, sensitive |
| Rosehip | 1 | Linoleic and linolenic | Light, silky | Combination, dull, mature |
| Castor | 1 | Ricinoleic | Very thick, sticky, slow | Lips, brows, heels, body, cleansing-oil blends |
| Jojoba | 2 | Wax esters (not triglycerides) | Light, silky, absorbs well | Most skin types, especially oily and combination |
| Apricot kernel | 2 | Oleic | Light to medium | Normal, dry, sensitive |
| Sweet almond | 2 | Oleic | Medium | Normal and dry |
| Moringa | 3 | Oleic | Medium to rich | Dry and mature |
| Avocado | 3 | Oleic | Rich, thick | Very dry, mature, body use |
| Coconut | 4 | Lauric | Rich; solid below about 24°C | Body, hair, dry feet |
The Three Oils Everyone Asks About
Jojoba (rating 2): widely used by people with oily skin. It is lightweight, stable and blends easily into the skin. Read more about jojoba oil benefits.
Hemp seed (rating 0): one of the lightest oils, rich in linoleic acid, and a favourite for oily and congested skin. See the benefits of hemp seed oil.
Rosehip (rating 1): silky but quick to absorb, thanks to its mix of linoleic and linolenic acids. A good fit for dull or mature skin. Wondering about breakouts? Read is rosehip oil good for acne-prone skin.
Why Jojoba Is Special: The Sebum Mimic
Jojoba is not technically an oil but a liquid wax, made of long-chain wax esters. That is why it feels light and silky instead of greasy, and spreads easily.
- It absorbs well and does not leave a heavy feel on the skin.
- Human sebum also contains wax esters, so jojoba feels familiar to the skin and blends in easily. This is why it is often called a carrier oil that mimics skin sebum.
- Many people with oily and combination skin find it balancing: moisturising without feeling greasy.
How to Choose a Carrier Oil for Your Skin Type
| Skin type | Good starting points | Go slowly with |
|---|---|---|
| Oily or acne-prone | Hemp seed, rosehip, jojoba, sunflower | Coconut, avocado, moringa |
| Combination | Jojoba, rosehip, argan, apricot kernel | Coconut, heavy blends on the T-zone |
| Normal | Argan, sweet almond, apricot kernel, jojoba | Nothing in particular |
| Dry or mature | Avocado, sweet almond, moringa, rosehip | Nothing specific; blend heavy oils with lighter ones |
| Sensitive | Sunflower, apricot kernel, jojoba | Fragrant oils, until patch tested |
| Body, heels, hair | Coconut, castor, avocado, sesame | None, apart from known allergies |
How to Use Carrier Oils Without Clogging Your Skin
- Patch test every new oil first: apply a little on the inner arm and wait 24 to 48 hours.
- If you are new to facial oils, start with 2 drops and increase slowly.
- Apply oil on slightly damp skin. It spreads more easily and helps lock in moisture.
- Introduce one oil at a time, so you can tell how your skin responds to each.
- If you use oils regularly, double cleanse at night so build-up does not sit on the skin.
- Store oils well, because an oxidised oil is more likely to irritate. Our guide on how to store cold pressed oils explains how.
Shop the Oils
- Pure Jojoba Oil: the sebum mimic, for most skin types
- Cold-Pressed Himalayan Hemp Seed Oil: light and linoleic-rich
- Himalayan Rosehip Oil: silky, for dull and mature skin
- Sweet Apricot Kernel Oil: gentle, for normal to dry skin
- Avocado Oil: rich nourishment for very dry skin and body
Conclusion
The best carrier oil is not simply the one with the lowest comedogenic rating. It is the one that suits your skin, your climate and your routine. People with oily or breakout-prone skin can start with light, linoleic-rich oils such as hemp seed, rosehip or jojoba, while people with dry skin often do well with richer, oleic-rich oils. Patch test, start small and let your skin guide you.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the comedogenic rating of natural oils?
It is a 0 to 5 scale showing how likely an oil is to clog pores. 0 means it is unlikely to clog, and 5 means it is highly likely. Ratings vary by source, so use them as a guide.
Which carrier oils mimic skin sebum?
Jojoba is the best known. It is a liquid wax made of wax esters, which are also found in human sebum, so it feels light and silky on the skin.
Can I use oil on oily skin?
Often, yes. Lightweight oils such as hemp seed, rosehip and jojoba are commonly used by people with oily skin. Patch test first and introduce one oil at a time.
Is a rating of 0 always safe?
No. A low comedogenic rating means the oil is less likely to clog pores. It does not mean you cannot be allergic or sensitive to it.
Is coconut oil bad for the face?
It is commonly rated 4, so it is more likely to clog pores, especially on acne-prone skin. It is more popular for the body, hair and feet.
Is castor oil comedogenic?
It is usually rated 1, but it is thick and sticky. Most people blend it with a lighter oil or use it on heels, lashes and brows.
How long should I test an oil before deciding?
Patch test for 24 to 48 hours, then use it on its own for 2 to 4 weeks to see how your skin responds.
Rosemary Hydrosol
Aloe Vera Gel